Grant was the better general overall. Lee would have been an outstanding Corp commander, but he lacked the strategic ability so necessary for one in his position. To put it another way, Lee knew how to win battles, but Grant knew how to win the war. Lee’s aggressive strategy came at a terrible cost for the South.
Who Wins Grant or Lee?
Although Grant suffered severe losses during the campaign, it was a strategic Union victory. It inflicted proportionately higher losses on Lee’s army and maneuvered it into a siege at Richmond and Petersburg, Virginia, in just over eight weeks.
Who was the best general of the Civil War?
There was no requirement of a balanced list, it just shook out that way, but we’ll see if our commentariat agrees.
- 1 Robert E Lee (Confederacy)
- 2 Ulysses S Grant (Union) …
- 3 William T Sherman (Union) …
- 4 Stonewall Jackson (Confederacy) …
- 5 Philip Sheridan (Union) …
- 6 Nathan Bedford Forrest (Confederacy) …
16 апр. 2015 г.
How were General Grant and General Lee different?
In terms of military tactics, both men were bold, decisive leaders. Lee is generally more praised for his tactical approach to particular battles, especially Chancellorsville, while Grant tended to be a more methodical leader, relentlessly putting pressure on the Confederate armies in order to exploit the numerical and …
Did Grant kill Lee?
Grant went on to defeat Robert E. Lee after another series of costly battles in the Overland Campaign, Petersburg, and Appomattox. After the Civil War, Grant was given his final promotion of General of the Armed Forces in 1866 and served until 1869.
Who was the worst Confederate general?
|General Braxton Bragg|
|Allegiance||United States Confederate States|
|Service/branch||United States Army Confederate States Army|
|Years of service||1837–1856 (USA) 1861–1865 (CSA)|
|Rank||Brevet Lieutenant-Colonel (USA) General (CSA)|
Why did Lee surrender to Grant?
Fact #4: Lee decided to surrender his army in part because he wanted to prevent unnecessary destruction to the South. When it became clear to the Confederates that they were stretched too thinly to break through the Union lines, Lee observed that “there is nothing left me to do but to go and see Gen.
Who was the South’s greatest general?
The most famous of them is General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson, probably the best known Confederate commander after General Robert E. Lee.
Who are the greatest generals of all time?
5 of the most incredible military leaders
- 10) Napoleon (1769-1821) …
- 9) William Slim, 1st Viscount Slim (1891-1970) …
- Jan Zizka (1360-1424) …
- 7) Genghis Khan (and his generals) (1162ish-1227) …
- 6) Gustavus Adolphus (1594-1632) …
- 5) Hannibal Barca (247BC-182ishBC) …
- 4) Arthur Wellesley, 1st Duke of Wellington (1769-1852)
Who was the most important general for the Union?
The Union’s main general was Ulysses S. Grant, but William Tecumseh Sherman, one of the firmest advocates of the so-called ”Hard War” policy, and George McClellan, known for being at odds with politicians and beloved by his troops, were other influential commanders as well.
What Grant thinks about Lee?
Grant certainly resented the way Lee was lionized by many, even in the North, as you can tell from his autobiography. Lee never wrote his autobiography, but you know he must have resented the destruction the Union army caused in his beloved state and envied the immense resources Grant had at his disposal.
Why was Lee such a good general?
Lee was a tactical genius who had the Union generals so cowed they were afraid to face him and, when the Confederates abandoned the field, afraid to pursue him. He regularly whipped Union forces twice the size of his inflicting twice as many casualties as he took. … Lee won every battle until Gettysburg.
What side was Robert E Lee on?
Robert E. Lee was a Confederate general who led the South’s attempt at secession during the Civil War. He challenged Union forces during the war’s bloodiest battles, including Antietam and Gettysburg, before surrendering to Union General Ulysses S.
Did US Grant die poor?
Grant, died broke. … Even before that, though, Grant had a reputation for spending more money than he had. He and his wife Julia lived the high life, indulging in luxurious travels and fine dining.
Did Grant Die Broke?
Shortly before noon on May 6, 1884, Ulysses S. Grant entered the office of his Wall Street brokerage firm a wealthy man. Hours later, he exited a pauper. Thanks to a pyramid scheme operated by his unscrupulous partner, Ferdinand Ward, Grant’s investment firm had instantly collapsed, wiping out his life savings.
How did Grant die?
On July 23, 1885, just after completing his memoirs, Civil War hero and former president Ulysses S. Grant dies of throat cancer.